Commander Damage is the term used to describe an alternate win condition in EDH. It states that if any player deals 21 points or more damage, with their Commander, to another player, that player is out of the game. This is over the 21 point threshold and means that Player 2 is out of the game.17 Nov 2021
Should Commander damage be removed?
Removing CD eliminates a viable route to victory and effectively neuters a popular strategy. This could fundamentally affect how people design their decks or play out games and many would argue it would be more restrictive.19 Feb 2020
Is Commander damage per Commander?
Yup! You sure can. The specific rule for commander damage doesn't specify that an opponent's commander had to deal the damage, just that a specific commander needs to deal damage. If you somehow take 21 or more damage from your own commander, you still lose the game.10 Nov 2021
Is Commander damage from all commanders?
You also need to remember that damage is tracked separately between commanders. That includes, of course, commanders owned by different players, but also partnered commanders owned by the same player. Each commander deals its own “instance” of Commander damage.22 Aug 2021
Is Commander damage shared?
The "commander tax", the additional cost of 2 for every time you've cast a commander from the command zone, applies individually. Combat damage dealt by each commander is similarly tracked individually.
How is Commander damage counted?
What is Commander Damage? A player that's been dealt 21 or more combat damage by the same commander over the course of the game loses the game. It's important to note that only damage dealt in combat, i.e. when a commander attacks another player, counts for Commander damage.22 Aug 2021
Can you take Commander damage from your own Commander?
Yes, you can make a player lose by dealing 21 total damage to them with their own commander. (If it keeps getting stolen by yourself or others, a cumulative total 21 damage from their own commander will make them lose.)
Is Partner Commander damage tracked separately?
In regards to your question about 1 player controlling 2 separate commanders, this can easily happen with the Partner ability, that allows you to have 2 Commanders. In this case, damage from each commander is tracked separately; you need 21 damage from the same commander to lose the game.29 Nov 2019
Does Commander tax apply to partners?
During a game of Commander, your partners function just like a single commander would. They both use the command zone, they're each subject to commander tax, and they keep separate tallies for commander damage. If a card of effect refers to “your Commander,” you get to choose which partner it applies to.10 Nov 2020
How does Commander damage work in Magic The Gathering?
Commander damage is a pretty simple rule. When your commander hits a player for combat damage (i.e., only during combat when the commander is attacking and is unblocked), notate how much damage that player has taken from your commander.10 Nov 2021
Does Commander damage have to come from the same Commander?
The specific rule for commander damage doesn't specify that an opponent's commander had to deal the damage, just that a specific commander needs to deal damage. If you somehow take 21 or more damage from your own commander, you still lose the game.10 Nov 2021
How much damage can you take from a Commander?
Commander Damage is the term used to describe an alternate win condition in EDH. It states that if any player deals 21 points or more damage, with their Commander, to another player, that player is out of the game.17 Nov 2021
Why does the Commander damage rule exist?
Conclusion. Commander damage is a unique rule that makes EDH the great format it is. It enables certain strategies, commanders, and even whole decks to be viable in the format, not to mention the added fun and threat to play around.22 Aug 2021