Arts and Entertainment What does vanilla pumpkin smell like? What does vanilla pumpkin smell like? Enriched with vanilla extract from Madagascar, your nose will twitch as it discovers the sweet, warm, baked pumpkin scent with hints of hazelnut caramel, maple syrup and almond milk. Related Posts:What is pure pumpkin?Does clear vanilla taste different?Is imitation clear vanilla extract the same?Is honey on a plant-based diet?